Видео

Umpires had to make the call WITHOUT REPLAY and ZOOM! In real time and at a distance. The right call was made even though replay overturns it. How would this call, and its review, be made in the days of no video?

That sure took a long time to figure out a pretty basic rule. They even had to call Daddy and Daddy had to explain again and again. Oh Boy.......

It’s not a reviewable play but they review it and overturn it !!!! Hilarious 😆😂

Catch. Dropped on transfer.

No catch .

I would call that a catch and the batter is out but I would return the runner to 1st base on the basis that because of the one umpire calling it a dropped ball he had to advance to second. If it was clear from the umpire's call that it was a caught ball he would have returned to 1st base ahead of the throw.

Why does this take a crew meeting? This is all on the Home Plate Umpire, he is in great position. Make the call, kill the play.

As an umpire I have catch and then loss on transfer.

Easily a catch and then drop on the transfer

The problem is the call is the plate umpires responsibility.. the runner is moving towards the 3rd base foul line.

At 2x speed I thought he dropped it. At normal speed it and a couple replays later, it’s a catch.

No catch !

Drop on the exchange it's an out

WOW this is a hard one to call. These Umps are doing the best with what they have. At least there was no helicopters attacking them.

That was a double play all day long. Drop during the process of getting ready to throw is after the catch.

TV6 cares for you!

If you're going to try to "exchange" while you're "catching", ya kinda gotta actually do BOTH at the same time. I call this a "drop".

It’s a catch the fielder dropped it on the exchange from glove to hand.

Definitely Not a Catch. Throwing hand never touched the ball trying to pull it out. (That’s what she said) Hits gloves, drops ball, picks it up off the ground. He went to go get it out of the glove, but dropped it first.

Catch. Dropped on transfer.

Horrible umpiring. Plate up never rules on fair/foul, makes no call regarding interference, then decides after the play to (correctly) call interference even though he didn’t actually see it nor call it. Disaster.

It was a catch. Fumbled in the transfer but had control initially.

A catch...but he won't make the minors with that exchange

It’s hard to argue with a routine fly ball. Maybe it wasn’t on the transfer (I think it was) but he didn’t deserve a hit. Lol

Under FED, there are 3 criteria for a catch…secure possession, secure possession through the voluntary release and a voluntary release. If you do not have all 3, you do NOT have a catch. Mechanically, umpires are trained to watch the player through the voluntary release and when a ball drops down, that was not secure possession and when a ball pops upwards AFTER being secured…then THAT was on the transfer. I would also point out that in a 2-man umpire system, U1 starts this play in the B position in the middle of the diamond to the 1B side. Catch/no-catch responsibility is SOLELY U1 here. PU’s responsibility is watching the touches at all bases since U1 has the ball. There should NEVER be two umpires working the same play! Know your responsibilities, pre-game your responsibilities and if you see someone taking a play they shouldn’t be taking you have to call them off, “Joe! I have the ball! Take the runners!”

ift probably is a catch and drop on exchange for one out, BUT with one ump calling safe you cant have a double play, he should have safe conduct back to first.

Catch, all the way.

Looked to me like he caught it and dropped it while trying to throw before it was in his hand

Sorry...don't drop it!!

That's a simp;le one. Catch.

Catch.

Legal catch, he is losing the baseball when in transition

Batter should be out I could see putting runner back on first if umpire signaled no catch

It was a catch

Out all day. The drop was on the exchange.

E-7 all the way.

catch

Dez Bryant said it was a catch!

"Hello Quad Cities' - 2002 Promo

It's back.

The batter also interfered with th3 catcher's attempt to field the ball.

This year's LLWS ups are really giving the pitchers that outside strike. Batters better come hit Geaux Texas Needville Texas is a very small town, what an achievement.

Correct call, but the throw from the catcher, unless on purpose, should have been further into fair territory with the 1st baseman more properly set up.

Damn 😢

Catch dropped while transferring the ball for a throw

Read rule 6.05(a) of the little league rulebook

Number 10 in goal is me on mankato

I think it is the right call. The ball came out of his glove before he got his hand in there to take it out so can't be called a transfer.

Several years ago I had this exact situation with 1 out and the runner on 1st left early. When the play was over a run had scored and a runner was thrown out at the plate. The defense can take any part ot the play that is to their advantage and nullify any part that is not to their advantage. In my case we put everyone back except we kept the out.

This is a terrible call! As an umpire, I saw the exchange right away! If anything, out to the batter/runner and the runner from first goes back due to the confusion. Easy umpiring situation here.